Birchard Books
Bill Birchard—Writing and Book Consultant
BILL'S BLOG ON WRITING
Mind the contract nits
Monday, February 3, 2020
In a once-in-a-decade event, the Authors Guild released its new “Model Trade Book Contract” in 2014. Though Guild members alone are privy to the document, the items of current interest are worth highlighting.
The topic most in the news, of course, is digital rights. The Guild believes authors should receive 50 percent of proceeds on sales of digital books. That’s in spite of the emerging publishing standard of 25 percent of net receipts.
How can authors possibly negotiate more than 25 percent? Guild lawyers have suggested that small, aggressive publishers could lead the way. Eager to snag a particular book, an acquiring editor could offer an author, say, 30 percent. Things could snowball from there.
Two other concerns are worth mentioning. The first is the “options clause,” which compels authors to give the publisher rights to, in essence, both first and last refusal on publishing their next book. That clause ties authors’ hands in redirecting their publishing future.
Guild attorneys urge authors to amend the publishers’ option-clause boilerplate. Don’t allow publishers the coveted right to automatically publish your next work on the same terms as the current one. Insist on flexibility—and require publishers to make their decision on your next book based on a proposal, not on a full manuscript.
The second concern worth mentioning is the “non-compete clause,” which forbids authors to publish competing works on the same subject until the current book is published. The non-compete clause can be a showstopper for authors who write on only one subject—especially when it’s their premier area of expertise.
Try to narrow the definition for subject matter considered competitive. Spell out exceptions to permit separate publication of blogs and articles on the same topic. Also limit the time period for which the clause is in effect so you can get started on your next book even if a publisher delays release of the current one.
The Guild’s model contract discusses 29 separate clauses in most publishing contracts. Almost any one of them—and their many additional sub-clauses—can trip up unwary authors. Publishers will remain unwilling to negotiate every single clause, but authors should be ready to target a half dozen items of key concern.
Join the Authors Guild to get the model contract yourself, an invaluable document (full disclosure: I’m a member). Members also get free advice from Guild attorneys on each and every contract they sign. This is a great deal.
In the meantime, plan to leave time in your book-development plans—at least six weeks—to conduct contract negotiations. In the long term, as the proverbial saying goes, the devil will be in the details you forgot to examine.
[Revised January 2020. Originally published December 8, 2014]